Do traps for codling moths work, two readers are asking after having their apple crop spoiled this year.
Judy from Omokoroa and Ben from Mt Maunganui are questioning the traps’ worth given the extent of fruit damage they have seen in their gardens this summer.
The short answer is they help but if plenty of adult moths are flying around in spring you won’t get 100 percent worm-free apples – or anywhere near that. The only way to have codling worm-free fruit is through diligent monitoring of moth numbers, combined with regular spraying when your apples are under threat. That is what most commercial orchardists do.
Few home gardeners want to. By the time you add up the spray cost, your time and the overall hassle, including exposure to pesticides, you might as well buy blemish-free apples and save yourself the bother.
However, if you want worm and spray-free home-grown apples, codling-moth traps help by taking some of the male moths (who fertilise the females’ eggs) out of circulation. It is done by attracting them to the sticky traps with a pheromone.
Ideally, all males would be trapped before they had time for any sexual sorties but it doesn’t work that way. Various factors come into play – such as trap numbers, where they are hung in relation to apple trees, whether strong winds reduce their effectiveness, and the number of adult moths that hatch in a season.
Determined gardeners get the best results when they supplement the traps with other anti-codling procedures. These include picking up all windfalls, keeping the ground tidy under trees, and removing flaking bark from older trunks and branches where over-wintering larvae can hide. It also helps to put bands of corrugated cardboard around big branches and tree trunks in summer and autumn.
They “catch” some worms looking for a cosy place to pupate, and need replacing regularly (burn infected ones).
Some gardeners say planting the feverfew herb and other plants at the base of trees helps, too.
The traps are probably the most expensive of all these options but among the least time-consuming. They are worthwhile but be realistic about their limitations. For the best overall results, combine them with other combat techniques.